Fossil fool?

A couple of weeks ago, West Virginia Attorney General J.B. McCuskey issued subpoenas to several environmental groups.

Two of the groups, the West Virginia Rivers Coalition and 350.org, responded by filing a lawsuit in federal court. 350.org is a nationwide environmental organization. In a court hearing October 29, US District Judge Joseph B. Goodwin put a temporary halt to the subpoenas until he hears the case on November 12.

The Sierra Club was also served with a subpoena, but that appears to have been withdrawn by McCuskey. There are several other environmental organizations that are rumored to have been issued subpoenas, but their names have not been made public. These subpoenas demand records that go back ten years. They ask for names of contributors, among other things. This has the appearance of a fishing expedition, which is what Judge Goodwin called it. The subpoenas allege that the organizations broke the law by lying to the public. Whew.

The actions that have garnered the AG’s attention seem to be that they cited US Government information about climate change. WV Rivers and 350.org signed onto a white paper that quoted government scientists stating a climate change outcome that McCuskey called a “flat-out falsehood.” So what?

I consider the attorney general’s action to be wrongheadedness cubed.

Firstly, in calling the statement a “falsehood” McCuskey is stating an opinion, not citing a fact. The paper in question offered five different climate change scenarios. The one our esteemed attorney general called a falsehood was labeled the “worst case” of five different scenarios. There is as yet no proof of the accuracy or inaccuracy of any of the scenarios.

Secondly, even if the scenario referred to by McCuskey can be proven to be inaccurate, that doesn’t mean it was a lie. A lie is a statement known to be untrue by the person making the statement. Making an inaccurate statement one believes to be true isn’t lying.

Thirdly, lying is permitted by the US Constitution’s First Amendment’s protection of free speech. I know this from the twenty-three primary and general elections in which I have been a candidate (seventeen of which I won). Most of my opponents criticized me fairly, and when they were inaccurate I could tell they were simply mistaken. But a very few made criticisms they later confessed they knew to be inaccurate. Even those statements were and are protected by the First Amendment.

Some time ago, when I had more disposable income than I now do, I contributed to the West Virginia Rivers Coalition for several years running. (Will this bit of info prompt J.B. to subpoena me?) I also did contract work for WV Rivers (my fee was in the low four figures) attempting to raise awareness of PFAs in our water. I say this in the interest of full disclosure. I think WV Rivers does splendid work protecting our environment.

The subpoenas in question reference the West Virginia Consumer Credit and Protection Act. But neither WV Rivers nor 350.org sells anything. I like and respect J.B. McCuskey. I’ve always regarded him as someone with a level head who is a straight shooter. But I’m perplexed by this preposterous action on the part of our state’s attorney general.

Perhaps J.B. sees an opening in the Republican Party for him to run for higher office. Two years ago, Patrick Morrisey won the Republican nomination for governor by a very tight margin in a three-way race. Morrisey is at the moment quite unpopular with the people of West Virginia, if polls are to be believed. By taking this action, McCuskey may be signaling to the fossil fuel industry that he’s on their side, and that they should consider supporting him for governor.

This is, of course, pure speculation on my part. Having begun speculating though, I shall continue down that road. If this move was an attempt to garner support for future election efforts, it might very well prove imprudent. Jason Huffman, Executive Director of the West Virginia Chapter of Americans for Prosperity (not generally regarded as a left-wing organization), responded to the AG’s action with what I call a “full Voltaire.” Here is his statement. “While we disagree with the environmental left’s rhetoric, there’s one thing we should agree on: they have a right to say it. Government has no prevailing interest in leveraging state-led investigations to put a thumb on the scale of a fight over policy or politics. The freedom of speech and of peaceful assembly are sacrosanct. And actions by government that, however well-meaning, chill free speech are antithetical to those unalienable rights.”


This article appeared in the Martinsburg Journal on November 10, 2026.